"Ah! there you have the folly of modern Liberalism, its half-cunning, half-silly way of getting at everything in a roundabout fashion.If neglecting children is an offence, and it IS an offence, then deal with it as such, but don't go badgering and restricting people who sell something that may possibly in some cases lead to a neglect of children.If drunkenness is an offence, punish it, but don't punish a man for selling honest drink that perhaps after all won't make any one drunk at all.Don't intensify the viciousness of the public-house by assuming the place isn't fit for women and children.That's either spite or folly.Make the public-house FIT for women and children.Make it a real public-house.If we Liberals go on as we are going, we shall presently want to stop the sale of ink and paper because those things tempt men to forgery.We do already threaten the privacy of the post because of betting tout's letters.The drift of all that kind of thing is narrow, unimaginative, mischievous, stupid...."I stopped short and walked to the window and surveyed a pretty fountain, facsimile of one in Verona, amidst trim-cut borderings of yew.Beyond, and seen between the stems of ilex trees, was a great blaze of yellow flowers....
"But prevention," I heard Margaret behind me, "is the essence of our work."I turned."There's no prevention but education.There's no antiseptics in life but love and fine thinking.Make people fine, make fine people.Don't be afraid.These Tory leaders are better people individually than the average; why cast them for the villains of the piece? The real villain in the piece--in the whole human drama--is the muddle-headedness, and it matters very little if it's virtuous-minded or wicked.I want to get at muddle-headedness.If I could do that I could let all that you call wickedness in the world run about and do what it jolly well pleased.It would matter about as much as a slightly neglected dog--in an otherwise well-managed home."
My thoughts had run away with me.
"I can't understand you," said Margaret, in the profoundest distress."I can't understand how it is you are coming to see things like this."10
The moods of a thinking man in politics are curiously evasive and difficult to describe.Neither the public nor the historian will permit the statesman moods.He has from the first to assume he has an Aim, a definite Aim, and to pretend to an absolute consistency with that.Those subtle questionings about the very fundamentals of life which plague us all so relentlessly nowadays are supposed to be silenced.He lifts his chin and pursues his Aim explicitly in the sight of all men.Those who have no real political experience can scarcely imagine the immense mental and moral strain there is between one's everyday acts and utterances on the one hand and the "thinking-out" process on the other.It is perplexingly difficult to keep in your mind, fixed and firm, a scheme essentially complex, to keep balancing a swaying possibility while at the same time under jealous, hostile, and stupid observation you tread your part in the platitudinous, quarrelsome, ill-presented march of affairs....
The most impossible of all autobiographies is an intellectual autobiography.I have thrown together in the crudest way the elements of the problem I struggled with, but I can give no record of the subtle details; I can tell nothing of the long vacillations between Protean values, the talks and re-talks, the meditations, the bleak lucidities of sleepless nights....
And yet these things I have struggled with must be thought out, and, to begin with, they must be thought out in this muddled, experimenting way.To go into a study to think about statecraft is to turn your back on the realities you are constantly needing to feel and test and sound if your thinking is to remain vital; to choose an aim and pursue it in despite of all subsequent questionings is to bury the talent of your mind.It is no use dealing with the intricate as though it were ******, to leap haphazard at the first course of action that presents itself; the whole world of politicians is far too like a man who snatches a poker to a failing watch.It is easy to say he wants to "get something done," but the only sane thing to do for the moment is to put aside that poker and take thought and get a better implement....
One of the results of these fundamental preoccupations of mine was a curious irritability towards Margaret that I found difficult to conceal.It was one of the incidental cruelties of our position that this should happen.I was in such doubt myself, that I had no power to phrase things for her in a form she could use.Hitherto Ihad stage-managed our "serious" conversations.Now I was too much in earnest and too uncertain to go on doing this.I avoided talk with her.Her serene, sustained confidence in vague formulae and sentimental aspirations exasperated me; her want of sympathetic apprehension made my few efforts to indicate my changing attitudes distressing and futile.It wasn't that I was always thinking right, and that she was always saying wrong.It was that I was struggling to get hold of a difficult thing that was, at any rate, half true, Icould not gauge how true, and that Margaret's habitual phrasing ignored these elusive elements of truth, and without premeditation fitted into the weaknesses of my new intimations, as though they had nothing but weaknesses.It was, for example, obvious that these big people, who were the backbone of Imperialism and Conservatism, were temperamentally lax, much more indolent, much more sensuous, than our deliberately virtuous Young Liberals.I didn't want to be reminded of that, just when I was in full effort to realise the finer elements in their composition.Margaret classed them and disposed of them.It was our incurable differences in habits and gestures of thought coming between us again.
The desert of misunderstanding widened.I was forced back upon myself and my own secret councils.For a time I went my way alone;an unmixed evil for both of us.Except for that Pentagram evening, a series of talks with Isabel Rivers, who was now becoming more and more important in my intellectual life, and the arguments Imaintained with Crupp, I never really opened my mind at all during that period of indecisions, slow abandonments, and slow acquisitions.
